Should the Clocks Stop Changing

Lawmakers in the United States and Canada are weighing whether to end the twice-yearly clock change and, if so, which time to keep. Here is where things stand, the main positions, and how each choice plays out by region. For how daylight saving time began, see The history of daylight saving time.

Where things stand

United States

Pending in the Senate

Under federal law, a state may already choose standard time all year, as Hawaii and most of Arizona do. Permanent daylight time needs an act of Congress. Many states have passed laws to adopt it if Congress allows; see the current list on our home page. In July 2026, the House passed the Sunshine Protection Act, 308 to 117, which would make daylight time the permanent standard. The bill is now with a Senate committee.

Canada

Decided by each province and territory

In 2026, British Columbia, Alberta, the Northwest Territories and Manitoba ended the twice-yearly switch, joining Yukon and Saskatchewan, and northwestern Ontario followed on November 1, 2026. Atlantic Canada and most of Ontario, Quebec and Nunavut still change their clocks.

What the debate is about

The question is often not only whether to stop changing the clocks, but which time to keep. Daylight time all year keeps today’s summer clock through the winter, so from November to March, sunrise and sunset come an hour later than now. Standard time all year keeps today’s winter clock through the summer, so from March to November, sunrise and sunset come an hour earlier. No clock setting adds daylight; it only shifts sunrise and sunset to different clock times.

Energy savings were the original reason for daylight time. When the Department of Energy measured the extra weeks added in 2007, it found total U.S. energy use fell by about 0.02%. Today’s discussion also centers on sleep, safety and how people use daylight.

Health arguments come in two kinds. One is about the switch itself, especially the hour of sleep lost each spring. The other is about which setting is kept all year. On that second question, the American Academy of Sleep Medicine favors standard time, arguing that later clock times push morning light later relative to the body’s internal clock. Its position statement notes that the long-term effects of year-round daylight time have not been well studied.

The three positions

Both permanent options would end the twice-yearly switch.

Daylight time all year

Supporters want to keep summer’s evening light through the winter, giving more daylight after work and school, and expect benefits for shopping, recreation and tourism.

Critics point to dark winter mornings, especially for children heading to school, and to 1974, when year-round daylight time was reversed after one winter.

Standard time all year

Supporters, including the American Academy of Sleep Medicine, say standard time best matches the body’s natural clock, because morning light helps set it.

Critics point to earlier summer sunsets, leaving less daylight after work and school than today.

Keep changing the clocks

Supporters see the current system as a balance: long summer evenings without the darkest winter mornings.

Critics point to the switch itself, which studies have linked to lost sleep and short-term health effects.

How it plays out by region

The same clock rule lands differently depending on where you are in a time zone and how far north you live.

Near the middle of a time zone, sun times are typical rather than extreme. Here is what each permanent option would change in St. Louis, close to the middle of the Central time zone:

Permanent daylight time

Later winter mornings

8:15 a.m.

Sunrise on the shortest day, December 21 (now 7:15 a.m.).

Winter sunset: 5:43 p.m. (now 4:43 p.m.).

Permanent standard time

Earlier summer evenings

7:29 p.m.

Sunset on the longest day, June 21 (now 8:29 p.m.).

Summer sunrise: 4:37 a.m. (now 5:37 a.m.).

Times for St. Louis, calculated for 2026. Actual sunrise and sunset can differ by a few minutes with terrain and weather.

Western edges of time zones already have late sunrises, because the sun reaches them later than the clock assumes. Under year-round daylight time, late-December sunrise in Indianapolis or Detroit would come around 9 a.m.

Eastern edges see the reverse. Under year-round standard time, summer sunrise in Boston would come around 4 a.m., with sunset before 7:30 p.m. That is one reason New England states have studied moving an hour ahead.

The North has the biggest swing between summer and winter days, so any choice is felt more sharply. Under year-round daylight time, winter sunrise in Seattle or Minneapolis would come close to 9 a.m.

The South has less seasonal change in day length, so the gap between summer and winter sunrise and sunset is smaller. Under year-round daylight time, winter sunrise in Miami would come around 8 a.m.

Across the border, the two countries have drifted apart. Western Canada no longer changes its clocks, while every U.S. state that observes daylight time still does. In winter, for example, British Columbia is now an hour ahead of Washington State.

Sources

Spot an error on this page? Report it